Kyokushin karate training

Shotokan Vs Kyokushin: Distinct Features Students Must Know

Contents

Photo by Ale RaFlo, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Generally, most of the world’s martial arts are related, but did you know that they can be further split into several variants depending on techniques, styles, and origin?

Did you know that there are different types of karate? Shotokan and Kyokushin are two of the best known, and they share some ideas and techniques.

So if you’re stuck between Kyokushin vs. Shotokan martial arts styles and don’t know which is the best for you, please read on.

Shotokan Vs. Kyokushin -- Differences & Uniqueness

The main differences surrounding Shotokan vs. Kyokushin are:

  • Shotokan sparring usually uses controlled, point-scoring strikes, whereas Kyokushin trains and competes with full-contact strikes.
  • Shotokan places heavy emphasis on kata (choreographed sequences of movement) and basics, whereas Kyokushin is known for hard sparring.
  • In Shotokan competition, you score points for clean, controlled techniques to target areas, whereas Kyokushin knockdown matches are won by knocking an opponent down or by the judges' decision.
  • Shotokan fighters get less full-contact experience, whereas Kyokushin fighters are used to hard contact, though neither style trains much ground grappling.

The Difference Between Shotokan And Kyokushin Karate

Shotokan Karate

Shotokan Karate

Kyokushin Karate

Kyokushin Karate

Karate is one of the most widely practiced martial arts, and it's split into several styles. Shotokan and Kyokushin are two of the most popular.

Both grew out of Okinawan karate and were developed in mainland Japan in the 20th century.

Shotokan emphasizes long, deep stances and powerful straight-line techniques, while Kyokushin built its identity around full-contact fighting. Kyokushin also absorbed influences from Goju-ryu and even Muay Thai: its founder sent fighters to face Thai boxers in the 1960s.

1. Origin

Shotokan comes from Gichin Funakoshi, an Okinawan teacher who introduced karate to mainland Japan in the 1920s. His followers formed the Japan Karate Association (JKA) in 1948 and 1949.

The name comes from "Shoto," the pen name Funakoshi used for his poetry, and "kan," meaning hall: his Tokyo dojo was called the Shotokan. His son Yoshitaka also shaped the style.

Kyokushin was founded by Masutatsu "Mas" Oyama.

Oyama trained in Shotokan under Funakoshi's organization and later in Goju-ryu, which helped him build his own hard-hitting style.

Kyokushin is often called one of the toughest karate styles, and it has many followers. Oyama opened his first dojo in Tokyo in 1954, and his Kyokushinkaikan headquarters opened in 1964. By 1960 he already had 72 branches in 16 countries.

2. Techniques

Both Kyokushin and Shotokan feature a wide range of striking techniques, including punches, knees, kicks, hand strikes, and elbows. But these styles differ when it comes to stance and approach when fighting.

Shotokan uses long, deep stances and favors straight punches and kicks from a distance.

In training, those strikes are aimed at specific targets and power is developed in basics and kata, but in sparring they're usually controlled.

Kyokushin uses a tighter fighting stance at close range, with hooks, body punches, low kicks, and knees. In knockdown competition, kicks to the head are allowed, but punches and other hand strikes to the head and face are not.

3. Challenges In Transitioning To Other Arts

Moving from either style to a grappling art takes adjustment. Moving from Shotokan to a full-contact striking art also has challenges, because Shotokan practitioners usually have less hard-contact sparring experience.

So transitioning from Shotokan to some martial arts like Muay Thai and kickboxing can be quite challenging. Fortunately, Shotokan techniques can be beneficial in other arts.

On the other hand, Kyokushin fighters can easily transition to other striking martial arts.

Kyokushin fighters spar with hard contact, so they're used to taking and landing strikes. Many Kyokushin fighters have gone on to kickboxing, and the style helped inspire K-1.

4. Philosophy

Both styles see karate as a way of life and a path to building character. Shotokan puts a lot of weight on precise technique and self-improvement.

Kyokushin puts its emphasis on toughness and testing yourself, so its training centers on hard, full-contact fighting. Full-contact sparring carries more injury risk, including a concussion risk from head kicks.

5. Tournaments

Both styles hold tournaments, but they look very different. Shotokan competitions usually include:

  • Kata
  • Point sparring (kumite) with controlled contact, like the WKF-style rules used in most sport karate

Kyokushin tournaments usually include:

  • Full-contact, bare-knuckle "knockdown" fighting
  • Kata
  • Tameshiwari (board breaking) in some events

In Kyokushin knockdown fighting, you win outright by knocking your opponent down or out, or else by the judges' decision. In WKF-style point sparring, you score 1 to 3 points for controlled punches, kicks, and techniques on a downed opponent.

Shotokan Vs. Kyokushin: Similarities

These two styles have several similarities, including roots in Okinawan karate. Oyama trained in Funakoshi's Shotokan before creating Kyokushin. Some major similarities include:

Attire

Both styles wear a white gi and use colored belts for kyu grades and a black belt for dan grades, although the belt colors in between differ. In both, white belts are beginners and black belts are experienced practitioners.

Knock-Out Point: Japanese martial arts have a colorful history. One of the older karate styles, with roots in Okinawa, is less familiar to many people. Read our article regarding this Karate variation here -- Goju Ryu Karate.


Watch This!


Frequently Asked Questions

How Long Will It Take Me To Get A Black Belt In Kyokushin And Shotokan Karate?

It varies by school, organization, and how often you train. Many students take roughly 3 to 5 years in Shotokan, and Kyokushin often takes longer because of its demanding gradings.

Kyokushin typically has 10 kyu grades before black belt. In Shotokan, the number of kyu grades varies by organization, often 8 to 10, and both styles have several dan grades after black belt.

Which Is More Effective In Street Fights?

Both types of karate can help with self-defense. Kyokushin's hard sparring gets you used to real contact, which many people see as an advantage. Either way, the best self-defense is avoiding the fight and getting away.

Which Is Easier To Learn?

Shotokan is usually easier on the body to start, since sparring is controlled. Kyokushin is more physically demanding, and its black belt gradings are known for being grueling.


Conclusion

Kyokushin and Shotokan are both karate, but they train very differently. Kyokushin is full-contact and more aggressive, while Shotokan focuses on precise technique, kata, and controlled sparring.

If you want hard contact and toughness training, choose Kyokushin. If you want a style that's easier on the body and strong on technique, Shotokan is a good fit.

Sources